I was never one to write strictly to a genre. From the very beginning, my writing defied neat boundaries — seeking comfort in familiar tropes while mixing in the unexpected. I’ve always believed that storytelling isn’t about following a set formula but about creating a bridge between the known and the novel. In this spirit, transcending genre has become my way of offering readers a reassuring anchor amid a sea of innovative narrative possibilities.

How Can You Tell When Something Transcends Genre?

One clear sign of a genre-transcending story is its ability to retain a deeply familiar core, even when its setting or trappings are stripped away. Imagine taking a space opera, with all its futuristic gadgets and interstellar intrigue, and transplanting its narrative into the rugged world of a cowboy tale. Despite the shift from starships to saloons, if the story’s heart — its themes, character dynamics, and emotional beats — remains intact and resonant, then you’ve witnessed the magic of a narrative that transcends its original genre.

Traipsing Across Genres

As a devoted anime fan, one series has always stood out to me as a beacon of genre-defying creativity: Cowboy Bebop. This classic anime blends space opera, noir, romance, and the spirit of the American old west, fusing futuristic escapades with a timeless, rugged charm.

Consider Afro Samurai — is it sci-fi? Is it fantasy? Or is it something entirely different? This enigmatic work is a testament to the endless possibilities of genre crossing.

For me, these inspired genre crossers exemplify the very essence of transcending genre — they show that when a story’s core is powerful enough, it can be reimagined in entirely different settings while still resonating on a deeply human level.

Is the Familiar Too Comfortable?

Genres are more than mere labels; they’re maps that help us navigate the narrative landscape. Growing up, I was captivated by the sweeping grandeur of high fantasy — the predictable beats of epic quests, the majesty of ancient lore, and the sense of wonder that transported me to magical realms. These familiar tropes provided a sanctuary, a kind of escapism from the daily drudgery of life.

However, as I matured and life revealed its complex, nuanced layers, I began to crave narratives that could capture more than just a singular, predictable rhythm. I wanted to express the intricate interplay of emotions, conflicts, and dreams that defy easy categorization — stories that mirror the multifaceted nature of real life, even if they don’t fit comfortably into a set genre.

A Fractured Landscape of Genrification

The turning point came when I began experimenting with the boundaries of genre, and I started writing the Slipshot series. In the Slipshot, I wanted to merge my characters’ experience of the sometimes bleak, futuristic world of Griddish with the gritty urban landscape of San Francisco’s Tenderloin District.

Griddish, with ancient, ordered, and unfathomable technology, stands in stark contrast to the worn, unfiltered realities of the Tenderloin — a district marked by a need for resilience, raw human experience, and survival. This collision of worlds not only offered readers a relatable anchor in the familiar chaos of urban life but also posed profound challenges for my characters. Some, hailing from the technologically advanced Griddish, found themselves grappling with the gritty, unvarnished culture of the Tenderloin — a confrontation that pushed them to adapt, rethink their identities, and find common ground in their shared humanity.

In addition to these dynamic settings, I also added elements of mystery and romance, further deepening the narrative layers and offering a more emotionally complex story. Would our protagonist Fredrick find love with his crush Jillian Crenshaw? Would he uncover the mystery that is unfolding before him? Would the teenager Cythiria be able to navigate the difficult waters of adolescence and relationships while being recruited into a war in a different dimension? Is the theme strictly Cyberpunk, or is this more of an aesthetic? The familiar elements provided a safety net, while the unexpected twists propelled the narrative into uncharted territory. This experiment reinforced my belief that when you juxtapose recognizable tropes with elements unfamiliar to them, you create stories that are unpredictable yet resonant.

Anchoring and Innovating

Achieving the delicate balance between comfort and novelty is a craft in itself. Over time, I’ve honed several techniques to bridge the gap between familiarity and innovation:

• Hybrid Tropes: I often begin with a classic archetype — like the reluctant hero — and place them in an unconventional scenario. This melding of old and new invites readers to reconsider what they thought they knew. Take, for example, Opal Fremmitty, the unlikely antagonist: an “alien” who’s become addicted to earthly liquors, smokes cigarettes, eats pizza, and even gives unsolicited romantic advice to Fredrick. Her character subverts expectations and adds a humorous yet heartbreaking layer of complexity to the narrative.
• Layered Narratives: While the surface story adheres to genre expectations, I embed subtle hints that allude to deeper themes. A familiar setting can quietly harbor unanticipated symbolism — consider, for example, the technology-based network known as the Tenddrome in Griddish, which serves as a near-spiritual experience for some, challenging their perceptions of reality and connectivity.
• Controlled Experimentation: Even when introducing abstract concepts, I ensure there’s a consistent narrative thread that keeps the reader grounded. For instance, in the Slipshot series, I added a unique layer of character development by dedicating extensive time to designing and illustrating our characters. With a series of character designs and key frame illustrations scattered throughout the book, I blended the written narrative with the visual storytelling elements of comics and manga. I even added rough concept art to demonstrate the process of producing a novel series like the Slipshot.

These methods are not foolproof; they require constant refinement and a willingness to embrace occasional missteps. Embrace is the operative word here. Embrace risk. Embrace failure.

Embrace Risk. Embrace Innovation.

Transcending genre is an enriching journey, but it comes with its share of risks. Blurring the boundaries between established genres often makes a story more difficult to categorize, which can impact its reach and ultimately, its sales. As an author venturing into these uncharted territories, you’ll likely spend considerable time educating your audience about what makes your work unique.

This approach requires more than just writing — it demands a deep commitment to building community and developing innovative marketing and outreach strategies. Unlike traditional genre works that allow for straightforward comparisons — “If you like X or Y, then you’ll like my story” — a genre-crossing narrative calls for a refined pitch and persistent effort to connect with readers. Ultimately, while the creative freedom of transcending genre offers boundless opportunities, it also requires patience, extra work, and a willingness to engage with your audience in novel ways.

Up up and away!

Transcending genre is, at its core, an ongoing adventure — a continuous exploration of how best to captivate and surprise. While familiar elements anchor us in a shared understanding, it is the courage to venture beyond these boundaries that transforms a story into an experience. I invite you, whether a fellow writer or an avid reader, to embrace this delicate dance between the known and the novel.

And see every story as a new opportunity to create a balance between comfort and innovation.

‍